Your browser (Internet Explorer 6) is out of date. It has known security flaws and may not display all features of this and other websites. Learn how to update your browser.
X

Posts tagged ‘Barefoot Running’

Why I run in Vibram Five Fingers

How I found Barefoot Running

Moab Half Marathon 2005
(My first Half Marathon & the pain that came afterward)

I can’t believe that it is finally Friday March 11, 2005. I thought (mostly hoped) this day would take a lot longer to arrive then it has. Sitting at work around four in the afternoon and my mind can’t seem to sit still. I drift off into worry land and back about the task that is at hand tomorrow. Jeanine, my beautiful wife knocks on the door at 4:30 and I have her come in the office as I turn off my computer and grab a last few things. Before I know it we are on our way to Moab to run in the Canyonlands Half Marathon. What on earth have I gotten myself into?

The last few months have been met with soreness and frustration. Shin splints seem to be my constant companion and I had to resort to running many weeks in the grass. As I reflected back on my previous runs, I wondered how on earth I would be able to run in this crazy person’s race(?)! I have always hated running my whole life and decided that I should try something different. Well this sure is different enough. What was I thinking? The miles between Orem and Green River seem to fly by and before I can grasp any sort of reality we are checking into our hotel for the night.

Just as I close my eyes to forget about the run of death I will do the next day, the alarm goes off. I open my eyes and the painstaking fear of doubt haunts my mind! Before I can realize where I am, or fully grasp what I am doing, I am sitting in a bus with my wife and some of her friends from her running group. We are making the long trek to the start line where I will do the dance of either shame or victory!! We arrive a half mile before the starting line where there are thousands of other runners. They are all talking, standing in line at the porta potty, huddling around a heater and some even trying to sleep. As I stand in line for the porta potty I take in my surroundings. The fear and doubt turn into excitement. I start to become assured of myself and the training I have done and doubt starts to fade. I see myself crossing the finish line. Hopefully not last but if so be it then a victory will still be celebrated!

moabhalfmarathon“I can’t believe I have had to use the restroom three times this morning!” We have now been standing around for close to 2 hours and an announcement is made to start making our way to the starting line. The half mile walk goes by so quickly and before I know it I am kissing Jeanine goodbye and leaving her at the 7 minute mile pace runners. I merge through the sidelines looking for my pace. I see 8 and then there is a 9 a lot further back, I think I see a 10 but no 11 or 12 or 13? WHAT THE HECK? Is everyone in this race speed demons? What about those of us who don’t have the legs and lungs of a gazelle? I think next year I will make a sign that says “Whoever wants to finish pace” and hold it up!

I finally make my way to the back of the pack. As I am standing there the warm sun has now hit me and my body warms up. I stretch out my calves so the shin splints won’t kill me to bad at the start of the race. Within a few minutes of stretching, a nice man and his wife start talking to me. I confess that this is my first half marathon and race altogether. They could probably tell due to my uncertainty. I made sure though I did not look to “Touristy”. I have the proper running attire, I have placed body glide on the places that my body needs to glide and I have been so hydrated that I could pee every 2 minutes if I wanted. What a nice couple though. They were telling me about the New York Marathon and several in California. Before I realize it the gun goes off. I can see the front of the runners take of running like there were fresh donuts back were we started walking from. It took a good 5 minutes of good solid walking to get to the start line and then the tail enders were off. I made sure that I did not overdue it to start as it is downhill for the first mile.

Running Injuries“Wow I feel great!!” Coming up on mile 2 and I am still feeling very good. The nervousness has gone and the calm peace of just trying to breath has settled in! There it is… the first water break. I try to grab my cup and drink while running only to find myself having to slow down to stop choking.. “Note to self… Walk through the water breaks if you want to finish and not choke to death.” I walked and finished the water and was off again. I keep seeing a lot of people running past me quickly and then see them walking a few minutes down the road. “Slow and steady, slow and steady. Humm, I didn’t tie my right shoe tight enough,” blister is starting but I am not stopping now in fear of not starting again. “Wow, I can not believe that mile 4 is almost here.” I have said hi to 2 people and many have told me good luck. “GOOD LUCK? Do I look that bad?” I soon figured out that this is a common saying to those who choose to stay behind to bring up the tail. Here it is water station and mile 4. Time to take out one of my Volcano Gels! “Ohh these things are so tasty.” My wife says they taste like flavored castor oil. If this is what castor oil tastes like sign me up for two servings! I think they taste delicious and give my taste buds a wakeup. On we go winding down the canyon and then up a hill. Around mile 5 I see a slow but gradual hill. Blister is killing me now. I know that it is the size of Arizona! Where did this hill come from? I did not see it when the bus brought us up here. Funny thing is I didn’t see any uphill when the bus brought us up. I am glad my mind played a trick on me and not let me see this before hand. Ok, just remember, you can do it. As I am halfway up the hill, a cycler comes behind us ringing a bell and shouts “come on runners take this hill!!” “Take this hill?” Yeah more like this hill will take me to my grave! Almost to the top and breathing is getting harder. “Wait a minute, I am almost there.” Ahhh… a little shade next to the side of the rocks, and some nice downhill. Here it is, mile 6 and more water! Thank goodness for water. “Gatorade, Gatorade” I hear people yelling. “WATER where is the water?” Ahh, finally a nice old gent hands me a nice cup of water. “WOW this water is cold. It isn’t warm like the ones before!” I savor every last drop and throw the cup.

Mile 7 isn’t so bad and the hills are more rolling than I had expected. Blister is roaring now and it won’t leave me alone! The map on the website made this course look like a downhill stroll. “Note to self, find out the true course map as the one they have on the website is there to lure people in…” Just before mile 8 a nice man jogs with me for a bit. His first words are “My legs are 2 miles back somewhere”. “Ha” I say. “Mine are 3 miles back, so you passed mine along time ago!”

Mile 8 is finally here and I am starting to get very hot and tired. I take my water and start back up around the bend. I no longer know if my feet and legs are attached. I just keep looking forward and run hoping they will follow my arms. Right now would be a good time to have a nap break! Just as I come upon mile 9 I see the one small hill I do remember seeing. SMALL?? Maybe to those that have been running for some time. All I see is GOLIATH standing there laughing… Wait a minute though, I hear some people just at the bottom of the hill. If I can make it there and get some water I will do just fine. Just as I get to the climb of the hill I realize they are not giving water. They are giving compliments…. Hummmm!! “Good job, you are almost there!” “Almost there? I am only on mile 9! I still have 4 more!!” Still I stay focused and want to tell them thanks but the lips will no longer move. I give them the thumbs up sign and trudge up the hill. Almost to the top I have to take a quick walking breather. Just as I top the hill there is the camera crew taking pictures… “HEY!!!! NO FAIR!!!” I start running so I don’t look like how I feel inside. Muscles are truly sore now. “Note to self, run more hills in training…….”

As I near mile 10 I can see the water station. I now know that this is by far the hardest thing I have ever done in my life. I hear the drums at the bottom of the canyon playing and hear people singing! I can do it. Jeanine said she would run back and run in with me. She said she would be there around mile 10. “Where is she?” I start back up the pace and I catch up to another guy that asks me “What are we doing this for again?” I laugh and continue on.

shin splintsI can now see the drummers and we cross under the freeway. Blister is now more than I can handle and body is done! Wore out and tired, ready to quit! Just as I am coming up the hill I see the best thing in the whole world. My wife is there and starts to smile. As I get closer to her I see her eyes and she is crying. She saw me and even though I had on my sunglasses I was crying as well. Nothing could have better than to see her there at that moment. She asked “How are you doing Jon?” I answer “I hurt and this is by far the hardest thing I have ever done!” She looks at me and says “I am so proud of you!!” I looked at her with tears streaming down my face I whisper, “I am doing it!!” We had to walk a little and now we are close to town and the heat is getting to me. We make it to water stop at mile 12. I have Jeanine get me 2 cups and I down them. As I pass a nice lady has a hose and asks “Want to get sprayed”. With all the energy I could muster I shake my head yes. She dowses me real good and some life comes back to me. “Just around that bend up there is the finish line” Jeanine says. I believe her but it seems so far away. Blister is now more than I can handle but I will not stop now! We round the corner and this was by far the most relieving site of the day. In big letters I read FINISH!! I can see it now. I don’t know why or how my legs are doing this but they are. Jeanine tells me she can’t run through the finish chute with me but runs off into the crowd. There is only 200 yards left now. Time to sprint. I hear cheers from all the other runners and people telling me I can do it. I am now in a full sprint. I want to slow down and walk but my mind tells me “NO! NO, Jon!! You have worked too hard and you are giving everything you have to finish this right now!!”I hear Jeanine’s voice “come on Jon, way to go! You are doing it!!” and I then hear my feet step on the finish line mat. “Thump Thump” I can now no longer stand and hit the ground right away by bracing myself up with my arms. A finisher’s medal is placed around my neck. I hobble over to the next stop to take off my time chip and grab water. My heart is feeling swelled now. I had done it. Tears start to stream down my cheek as I realize that I have accomplished something I never thought I could or even wanted to do! I did it! I finished!!! I drink 2 bottles of water and start on my 3 rd. I eat 2 bananas and am ready to now relax! This is the best part of the race! I take of my shoes, and Jeanine’s eyes get big. “Jon, holy cow that looks so painful!” I told her that I did not want to complain much so I didn’t say anything. It didn’t matter now. It was a war wound from a war I have just won! What a victory!

barefoot running shoes
Runnging Moab in Vibram Five Fingers

Little did I know what would happen next.. The next two weeks I could barely walk and there was horrible pain in my shins. Both sides! The xrays that were taken were positive that I now had stress fractures!! Great!! Now I could no longer run, get in shape or loose weight. So what to do now? Well I wanted to be able to run! The feelings of finishing the half marathon were a high I wanted to experience over and over again!! So after watching what I eat, loosing 10 lbs over two months of healing, I took to running again.. The first mile I was TICKED!! My pain was back again. What was going on?? I was so upset! I remembered reading in one of my wife’s Runners Worlds about a man (Barefoot Bob) and how he ran barefoot to be pain free. So, I sat down, took my shoes off and started running barefoot.. I had to slow down some and keep on a paved path, but WOW!! No more shin pain! No more pain at all!!! Maybe this barefoot thing had something to it!! I started out slow and picked it up over time.. I had to tape my toes from blisters, but over time, I have dropped over 60 lbs. My second year at moab I ran it in 2:08!! Wow!! I have evolved to running in Vibram Five Fingers now. Checkout my reviews and updates throughout the site!!

More Barefoot Running Proof… It isn’t “NEW”

Thanks to Steve for sending me this article from the Sports Science Journal..
Alot of people think barefoot running is some new fad, or invention… These studies were done LONG before the latest trends started to pick up. I am including the link at the bottom if you want to download the article in full!!

One of the most common chronic injuries in runners is planter fasciitis, or an inflammation of the ligament running along the sole of the foot. There is some evidence that the normally unyielding plantar fascia acts as the support for the medial longitudinal arch, and that strain on the proximal fascial attachment during foot strike leads to plantar fasciitis (Robbins and Hanna, 1987). Barefoot running may induce an adaptation that transfers the impact to the yielding musculature, thus sparing the fascia and accounting for the low incidence of plantar fasciitis in barefoot populations (Robbins and Hanna, 1987).

Chronic ailments such as shin splints, ilio-tibial band syndrome and peri-patellar pain are attributed variously to excessive pronation, supination, and shock loading of the limbs (Siff and Verkhoshansky, 1999, p.451). When running barefoot on hard surfaces, the runner compensates for the lack of cushioning underfoot by plantar-flexing the foot at contact, thus giving a softer landing (Frederick, 1986). Barefoot runners also land mid-foot, increasing the work of the foot’s soft tissue support structures, thereby increasing their strength and possibly reducing the risk of injury (Yessis 2000, p.124).

Wearers of expensive running shoes that were promoted as correcting pronation or providing more cushioning experienced a greater prevalence of these running-related injuries than wearers of less expensive shoes (Robbins and Gouw, 1991). In another study, expensive athletic shoes accounted for more than twice as many injuries as cheaper shoes, a fact that prompted Robbins and Waked (1997) to suggest that deceptive advertising of athletic footwear (e.g., “cushioning impact”) may represent a public health hazard. Anthony (1987) reported that running shoes should be considered protective devices (from dangerous or painful objects) rather than corrective devices, as their capacity for shock absorption and control of over-pronation is limited. The modern running shoe and footwear generally reduce sensory feedback, apparently without diminishing injury-inducing impact–a process Robbins and Gouw (1991) described as the “perceptual illusion” of athletic footwear. A resulting false sense of security may contribute to the risk of injury (Robbins and Gouw, 1991). Yessis (2000, p.122) reasoned that once the natural foot structures are weakened by long-term footwear use, people have to rely on the external support of the footwear, but the support does not match that provided by a well functioning foot.

Measurements of the vertical component of ground-reaction force during running provide no support for the notion that running shoes reduce shock. Robbins and Gouw (1990) reported that running shoes did not reduce shock during running at 14 km/h on a treadmill. Bergmann et al. (1995) found that the forces acting on the hip joint were lower for barefoot jogging than for jogging in various kinds of shoe. Clarke et al. (1983) observed no substantial change in impact force when they increased the amount of heel cushioning by 50% in the shoes of well-trained runners. Robbins and Gouw (1990) argued that plantar sensation induces a plantar surface protective response whereby runners alter their behavior to reduce shock. The less-cushioned shoe permitted increases in plantar discomfort to be sensed and moderated, a phenomenon that they termed “shock setting”. Footwear with greater cushioning apparently provokes a sharp reduction in shock-moderating behaviour, thus increasing impact force (Robbins and Hanna, 1987; Robbins et al., 1989; Robbins and Gouw, 1990). However, in these studies the subjects ran on treadmills or force platforms. Further studies are needed to establish how shoes affect impact force and shock-moderating behavior on natural surfaces such as road or grass.

Other features of footwear, such as arch supports and orthotics, may interfere with shock-moderating behavior and probably hinder the shock-absorbing downward deflection of the medial arch on landing (Robbins and Hanna, 1987). These features reportedly reduce pronation and supination or offer the wearer lateral and arch support. They may help some people with foot pathologies, but their benefit is uncertain for runners with healthy feet (Yessis, 2000, p.121).
Runners with diminished or absent sensation in the soles of the feet are particularly vulnerable to damage or infection when barefoot. Peripheral neuropathy is a common complication of diabetes mellitus and may result in the loss of protective sensations in the feet. Barefoot locomotion is therefore not recommended in this population (Hafner and Burg, 1999). Indeed, proper footwear is essential and should be emphasized for individuals with peripheral neuropathy (ACSM/ADA, 1999; ACSM, 2000).
Economy
Wearing shoes increases the energy cost of running. Burkett et al. (1985) found that oxygen consumption during running increased as the amount of mass they added to the foot increased; shoes and orthotics representing 1% of body mass increased oxygen consumption by 3.1%. Flaherty (1994) found that oxygen consumption during running at 12 km/h was 4.7% higher in shoes of mass ~700 g per pair than in bare feet. An increase in oxygen consumption of ~4% is of little importance to the recreational runner, but the competitive athlete would notice a major effect on running speed.
The increase in oxygen consumption with running shoes could have several causes. An obvious possibility is the energy cost of continually accelerating and decelerating the mass of the shoe with each stride. Another possibility is the external work done in compressing and flexing the sole and in rotating the sole against the ground–up to 13% of the work done in walking, according to Webb et al. (1988). Frederick (1986) reported that oxygen consumption increased substantially with thicker shoe inserts during treadmill running. Not surprisingly, materials used for cushioning in shoes absorb energy, and stiff midsoles should produce a 2% saving of energy compared with standard midsoles (Stefanyshyn and Nigg, 2000). Finally, shoes probably compromise the ability of the lower limb to act like a spring. With bare feet, the limb returns ~70% of the energy stored in it, but with running shoes the return is considerably less (Yessis, 2000, p.123).
Adapting to Barefoot Running
Thirty minutes of daily barefoot locomotion is a recommended starting point to allow thickening of the sole of the foot and adaptation of muscles and ligaments (Robbins et al., 1993). Begin by walking barefoot at every reasonable opportunity then progress to jogging, gradually increasing the intensity and duration (Yessis 2000, p.124). After 3-4 weeks, the plantar skin eventually becomes robust and allows longer periods of barefoot running at higher average velocities (Robbins et al., 1993). To facilitate adaptation, perform progressive strengthening exercises for the foot and ankle, including foot inversion, toe flexion, and walking on the balls of the feet. Barefoot locomotion on uneven surfaces will also help stimulate the plantar surface and provide increased sensory feedback (Yessis 2000, p.125).
Conclusions
• Running in shoes appears to increase the risk of ankle sprains, either by decreasing awareness of foot position or by increasing the twisting torque on the ankle during a stumble.
• Running in shoes appears to increase the risk of plantar fasciitis and other chronic injuries of the lower limb by modifying the transfer of shock to muscles and supporting structures.
• Running in bare feet reduces oxygen consumption by a few percent. Competitive running performance should therefore improve by a similar amount, but there has been no published research comparing the effect of barefoot and shod running on simulated or real competitive running performance.
• Research is needed to establish why runners choose not to run barefoot. Concern about puncture wounds, bruising, thermal injury, and overuse injury during the adaptation period are possibilities.
• Running shoes play an important protective role on some courses, in extreme weather conditions, and with certain pathologies of the lower limb.

What was the saying?? Father Knows Best!!

God created us, so I believe he knew what he was doing even if we  are just finding that out several thousand years later!! I find it funny that science is finally now giving some thought to what more and more of us have found earlier and were considered wack jobs…… I guess the first guy to put a hotdog on a stick, dip it in batter and deep fry it was considered odd as well..

barefoot running
The comparing of foot strikes

[ad#basic-large-rectangle]
“Running barefoot or in minimal shoes is fun but uses different muscles,” said Harvard professor Daniel Lieberman. “If you’ve been a heel-striker all your life, you have to transition slowly to build strength in your calf and foot muscles.” (Credit: Image courtesy of Harvard University)
[ad#basic-large-rectangle]
A great article on unshod running was posted on Science Daily this week. My favorite part was the following: “Our feet were made in part for running,” Lieberman says. But as he and his co-authors write in Nature: “Humans have engaged in endurance running for millions of years, but the modern running shoe was not invented until the 1970s. For most of human evolutionary history, runners were either barefoot or wore minimal footwear such as sandals or moccasins with smaller heels and little cushioning.”
[ad#basic-large-rectangle]
The article in full can be read here: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/01/100127134241.htm

RUN FUN RUN FREE ~UnshodRunner

Barefoot Running Benefits

The denver post had some great debate on the Pros and Cons of running barefoot. This image I believe sums it up for me and how I have come to know that running unshod has made me a stronger INJURY free runner!!
[ad#basic-large-rectangle]

Barefoot Running Benefits

[ad#basic-large-rectangle]